4 Comments
User's avatar
Rebecca Wald's avatar

Eli, I appreciate this piece and your pointing out that labels like “Zionist” and “anti-Zionist” might mean very different things to different people. But shouldn’t the same caution extend to labels like the “Am Yisrael Chai” crowd. That phrase expresses something meaningful to many Jews who may hold vastly different views about Israel, its government, and the war in Gaza. Not everyone (i.e. me) is so clued into the nuance of what a particular expression/word carries in its most popular context. When we attach a particular political outlook to a familiar expression of Jewish identity and solidarity, don’t we risk doing what your piece warns against?

Eliyahu Ungar-Sargon's avatar

I hear you and it’s true that that phrase means different things to different Jews. But one group has really adopted it over the last three years and that’s the hyper-Zionist Jews that I’m talking about here. It’s a little like people calling Palestine solidarity folks the “From The River To The Sea” crowd. The problem isn’t calling them that. It’s suggesting that the phrase only means one thing. No one denies that the chant is popular.

Rebecca Wald's avatar

Fair—it’s popular with that group. But that’s my point. Once we name people by a phrase, we assume we know what they mean. Same with “the River to the Sea crowd.”

Eliyahu Ungar-Sargon's avatar

I do know what hyper-Zionists mean when they use the phrase. And that doesn’t mean that it’s the only possible meaning.